 |
One of the things I really like about this toy is that it's not just about the One Right Answer. My daughter (now 2-1/2) experiments with different ways to insert the same shape, and learns something about generic versus specific solutions. There is much value in the notion that only the star can go through the star-shaped hole, but the star and many other blocks can pass through the rectangular one.
Similarly, the fact that the lid can fall off used to annoy her. But it also taught her to adapt to it, and now she either holds the lid on or turns the box in such a way as to not drop it off.
I admit she found this toy frustrating early on. But it is one of those toys that she revisits every few months, and she plays with it differently over time. Her "plain" shape sorter was a good first lesson for her, but it doesn't have anything new to offer once she figured out how to get the three different shapes into the three different holes. This toy has a lot more to offer over time.
28.) she loves it!!
Reviewed by: ginnysmommy Bells, TN USA
Rating:
I was suprised to read the negative reviews about this product! My 19-month-old daughter LOVES this toy at her grandmother's house! The problem with the lid coming off was EASILY remedied by applying stick-on velcro to two of the tabs on the lid. (Get some imagination, people!!) My little girl got quickly bored with the four-shape plastic shape sorter. I have been amazed at how quickly she has learned the names of the shapes and where they go. I am recommending this toy to the other grandmother to have at her house!!
29.) USE VELCRO and all is well, and you have a great toy!
Reviewed by: C. Farrelly Everywhere, USA
Rating:
I have read so many reviews about people complaining about the top lid being loose. And, I agree that this should be addressed in any future making of this product. BUT, this is SO easy to fix. Go to the store, but some stick-on velcro and cut two small pieces to fit on two of the sides of the lid (I say two sides, because I did all four, and I actually had a hard time prying off the lid, ironic)! :-) This fixed the problem and the shape-sorter works great.
I have also read some reviews about the shapes fitting other holes. I don't know if they got one that was defective, but I took my shapes and tried this, and it IS NOT possible, at least with mine.
Also, the point of this shape-sorter is to be more difficult than the average, this is for a slightly older toddler. I bought this for my son (who just turned 3) because he love sorting shapes, but the "baby" ones were too simple. So, he is really enjoying this one. There are shapes that he gets frustrated with and then needs help, but I would only consider this a positive, because it is a great learning opportunity! In fact, I would have been disappointed in this toy if there hadn't been some difficutly.
Finally, I would address the size of the pieces. I know one reviewer said they could fit in her childs mouth. I am looking at mine and think this might be possible, but I could not see any child being able to even attempt to swallow one. They are just too large.
So, I would really recommend this toy. I know you now have the "hassel" of putting on the velcro, but it takes no time, and completely takes away the frustration of having the lid fall off, thus making this a great toy. This is the only reason I gave the toy 4 stars, if the lid didn't fall off, it would be 5.
30.) My son loved it...
Reviewed by: M. Foran New Orleans, La. United States
Rating:
My son received this as a present for his first birthday. He just turned two and is still playing with it on a regular basis.
It has absolutely helped his to learn his shapes, but we have had to do some facilitating and helping (instead of just putting the toy in front of him and letting him have at it). I don't consider this a minus--perhaps some parents do?
I believe he still plays with this toy because it still challenges him. And there is nothing he loves more than to dump out the shapes (this is where the unattached lid comes in handy!), then spend several minutes working to find the right holes to fit the blocks. This toy is also one of the first to come out when he has friends over; the toddlers I've observed really seem to enjoy it.
31.) Despite other reviews, MY kids like this one a lot!
Reviewed by: D. Shetka Sunny CA
Rating:
My kids (girl ages 2-1/2 and boy 1-1/2) have had lots of fun with this toy. The older (girl) got it when she was about a year old. The only negative I have observed with their play is that sometimes when the shapes have collected at the bottom of the toy they preclude/obstruct adding other shapes into the box. As for the top coming off, that hasn't seemed to bother the kids at all. It IS a more advanced shape sorter, but since we already had a simple "3-shape" sorter toy it has been a fun challenge for the children.
(Added 2 years later: My kids are now 3-1/2 and 4-1/2 and they still from time to time pick this one up and play with it. WOW!)
32.) Nice learning toy
Reviewed by: mechanical engineer Kuwait
Rating:
very clear and direct to the kid mind.
nice way to learn specialy for kids who speaks english as there second language.
33.) The way toys aught to be made
Reviewed by: mumto4boys USA
Rating:
This is a well made, sturdy toy. The shapes are brightly coloured and attractive to children.
I was nearly put off by the bad reviews regarding the lid. But my nearly two-and-a-half year old has no problem with it. He fits in the shapes on the sides first and finally searches for the ones on the lid.
He enjoys the easy opening and closing and likes to tip out all the blocks when he has finished.
Guest's children have also enjoyed this toy.
Thank God there are still companies willing to make good quality products.
A parent tired of poorly made, cheap toys.
34.) A Little Complicated, but fun
Reviewed by: zrma3 TN
Rating:
I got this toy for my 2 year old son. A few of the shapes are very similar so I had to help guide him on some of them, but when he got one in the correct place he was so proud. We have only had it for a short while, but I think it is going to be a great teaching tool for my son. He likes all of the different colors as well. I would recommend this toy to parents of 2 year olds and above.
35.) loose lid
Reviewed by: Angela Kroboth Redondo Beach, CA USA
Rating:
I love the colors of the blocks and the unique shapes. My son plays with the toy occasionally but only because he is still a bit too young (14 months old) to appreciate the shape sorting. I do wish the lid was attachable and I actually put strips of velcro on it to keep it in place as my son turns it upside down.
36.) fun if not thrown
Reviewed by: Andrew J. Mclemore New Bedford, MA
Rating:
great durablity and bright colors, but hurts if thrown at or stepped on in bare feet.
37.) fun for toddler
Reviewed by: N. Yanagidate United States
Rating:
My two-and-a-half year old son loves this toy! However, I bought this for him when he was one-and-a-half and, unfortunately, he broke the top.
The top of the block is definitely flimsy and breaks easily. My husband super-glued it, and, so far, it's staying together.
My son loved fitting the shapes into the holes when he was a little younger and now loves it because he's learning the names of the shapes. This is a toy that has grown with him.
What more can you ask?
A little more durable maybe?
38.) fun for a kid
Reviewed by: kcar74 Gillette, WY USA
Rating:
The paint on the shaped blocks rubs off on the
plain wood, so you get little stripes on the
cube. It seems to be durable enough and I like
the "old school" toys mixed in with the newer
ones. I think it's a good toy for that.
39.) Mom of a two year old
Reviewed by: C. Mullenhour
Rating:
We bought this toy for our daughter for Christmas (4 months before her second birthday). She loves to learn, and we thought it would be great to help her learn shapes & colors. She loves it!!!! Just by sitting down to play with her, she knows all the names of the shapes- even trapezoid & octagon. Since then, she loves to sort them by color. A great investment for any child who loves to learn!!!!!
40.) Fun to do together
Reviewed by: Julie Pennsylvania
Rating:
I gave this toy to my daughter when she was 16 months old (knowing full-well that the recommended age was 2 years). She took to it immediately, and with a little help was soon putting all the shapes in the correct holes. I did have to hold the lid down for her and turn the cube so that the proper hole was on top. This is the one annoying feature about the toy design - because the lid won't stay on if the cube is turned, an adult has to assist. But it has become one of our favorite activities to do together, and now at 22 months, she loves it as much as she did when she first got it. And she has learned the names of many obscure shapes: octagon, pentegon, etc. She actually calls the toy "oc-tees" because the octagon is her favorite! In spite of the one design flaw, I love this toy and would recommend it to others. But not all kids may have the patience for the challenge of this type of toy, and certainly perhaps not before the recommended age. Based on reading other customer reviews, I would judge our experience to be unusual.
41.) Nice buy for little kid around age 1+
Reviewed by: P. LEE Flushing, NY
Rating:
I bought this for my daughter and she loved it at the first time she saw. The colors are bright and attractive. The shapes are just right for them to hold on their hands. This is more educative than other small toys such as cars or dolls.
42.) Educational but design is questionable.
Reviewed by: risitas29dn Chicago, IL
Rating:
I disagree with some of the reports. It isn't hard to get the other shapes in the hole when it starts to fill up....gravity...the blocks fall to the bottom. However, the lid stayed on ours it was a good fit but the lid eventually broke. Maybe it was too tight and that is why it broke instead of being too loose. I have tried other shape sorters by other manufacturers since and my son enjoys this one the best. The others are built pretty poorly or they are too easy for him. No win situation. For $10-15, I guess it is worth it.
43.) Let's Give It Four.
Reviewed by: Gary Peterson San Diego, California USA
Rating:
Our boy just had his first birthday party and one of the gifts he received was a Melissa and Doug Shape Sorting Cube. The manufacturer says it's for children of 2 and up, so I guess the gift is a bit ahead of the game. That's OK. Right now, our boy uses the little blocks for bashing on things and for chewing on. The top also gets a certain amount of chewing around the corners.
In any case, it's a nice wooden toy, in contrast to many of his other plastic toys and almost all seem to be Made in China. I cringe at the brightly painted pieces and hope that the paint is safe. So many things from China turn out to be tainted, these days. I guess this Shape Sorting Cube is educational in that it can be used to learn shapes and colors and help in counting and reasoning skills. Well, so be it. Will the kid enjoy it as a toy? Who Knows? We'll just have to wait beyond the bashing and chewing stages. Would I have enjoyed it and found it a good learning experience? Probably marginal, at best. So how shall I rate it? I'll give it four stars. My feeling is three, but it hasn't been tested by the boy as yet and my hopes are he would rate it a five.
Gary Peterson
44.) Good buy for the price
Reviewed by: Nikhil Hegde Austin, TX
Rating:
Pros:
Good value for money
Made of light wood, durable
Cons:
The box is hollow, so if you put the shapes into their slots all the way, they just fall into the box. I had to put a smaller box in, so my son could play with the shapes without wanting to open the box each time.
45.) TWO different varieties - choose the right one!
Reviewed by: Mother of Two Babies Tyler, TX
Rating:
Okay, there are two varieties of these cubes, and the difference is subtle but significant. We purchased one that looks EXACTLY like the one pictured but the brand was Imaginarium. It's a great classic toy that my 19-month-old loves and can pretty much complete independently. However, the one we bought has a removable side that merely sits in place. Obviously that is a terrible design decision, because when you rotate the cube to reach the other sides, the top falls off, spilling the contents. I had to glue some magnetic strips on it to hold it in place while my daughter plays. There is an almost identical toy (often pictured interchangeably with the ones shown as Melissa & Doug) which has a slide-in-place closing side. That seems like a MUCH better idea! So please do buy this toy, but I advise you to choose the one with the slightly better design, if possible.
46.) Challenging Shape Sorter, Great Toy, Manage the Frustration!
Reviewed by: Colorado reader & parent Colorado Springs, CO
Rating: 
My 22 month old daughter plays with this toy, but there are 2 major sources of frustration.
1) The lid doesn't stay on well - whenever you try to put a shape into the side with the lid, the lid flips over. An older child could probably figure out that you have to hold the lid (or just drop the shape neatly into the hole without touching the lid) - but a younger toddler just isn't going to get that. It is very frustrating. Other people have pointed it out as well - perhaps the designers will respond in version 2. It's needlessly frustrating.
2) Some of the shapes are very similar /complicated - it is frustrating for a young toddler. BUT!!!! my daughter is slightly younger than the recommended age, and, it is a learning toy - it isn't supposed to be immediately easy. Just know that for younger toddlers, you should play with them and help them select the right hole.
A bit of guided play is called for while they are learning and it will increase fun/decrease frustration. My daughter has learned some of the shapes on her own, and is getting 'closer' on some of the others, but I frequently play with her and talk to her about the shapes and help her find where they go.
All in all, it is a good toy. We have several Melissa & Doug toys, and have been pleased with them all. They are safe, high quality, and nice looking. And you can never have too many small, brightly colored pieces of wood underfoot. :)
47.) what a mess
Reviewed by: Kitara Tokyo, Japan
Rating:
My son is 2 1/2 years old and we bought this for him last Christmas (2001). We were looking for something along this line and being from Imaginarium I thought it would be good. There's a major error in the design of the toy. The blocks fit in numerous different holes so there's no reason to find the correct hole to put the correct shape in. The rectangle turned sideways fits in at least 3 or 4 different holes.
So, as a learning toy there are other sorting blocks that are much better. My son has more fun throwing the blocks around. He loves to put the blocks in the holes and he does enjoy the toy. It is well made and sturdy, but as an educational toy it is lacking.
48.) nice price for the product
Reviewed by: SKS illinois, USA
Rating:
My son loves this toy. The main problem is that the removable side (used to retrieve the shapes) falls off all the time. It would have been perfect if the top fitted tight enough to stay when the box was turned.
49.) Wood is better than plastic, but...
Reviewed by: S. Pershall Waukesha, WI USA
Rating:
I was thrilled to find this Wooden Shape Sorting Cube so it could replace our plastic one. When it came, however, I immediately thought of putting hinges and a snap or closure device on the cover so that we couldn't misplace the top and so that kids could use the top shape sorting panel just as easily as the other sides and that it would remain one whole block. Within the first week my two year old split the cover - it is too week with the shapes cut out of a single unsupported piece. We suspect he either hit it with his toy hammer or steped on it. We're going to have to gorilla glue it so he can play with it again. Conceptually it is wonderful - an oldie but a goodie! Structurally, it could use some work.
50.) Good quality, but design flaws
Reviewed by: Husband, Father, Catholic, Finance Professor, Portfolio Manager, and High Priest of NuclearPhynance Ile de France
Rating:
We wanted wooden toys for our kids, but I have to say the Tupperware shape sorter is the one that gets used most.
We passed on this one and bought a handcrafted no-name shape sorter at a craft fair, mainly because the lid was hinged and our daughter liked that feature (she endlesly opened and closed it). The Mellisa and Doug shape sorter lid is not fixed, and struck me as another element to possibly get lost and diminish the utility of the toy.
Still, the quality of construction struck me as excellent. It isn't the best, but it is more than adequate.
51.) longer-term effects
Reviewed by: cwwees Tucson, Az USA
Rating:
My daughter got this at 9 months. We played with it a little. Six months later, it was still in use, but not much. Now, she's about to turn 5 yrs and still plays with it intermittently, as well as mixing these blocks with other wooden blocks and using the box as a foundation for towers.
At 3-4 yrs old, she was much more intent on finding the matching hole than at 1-2 yrs. Now, she manipulates her doll to put the blocks in.
The plastic shape-sorters? They've been ignored since 18 months. I suspect bad reviews come because the toy is a little too complicated for an infant's first shape-sorter.
52.) So-so
Reviewed by:
Rating:
I read these reviews before I bought this toy so I knew that the lid didn't stay on and I bought it anyway. Another problem about this is that the shapes don't all fit in the toy easily. You have to shake the toy (and hold the lid) to move the other shapes out of the way for the other ones to fit in properly. I would look for a different shape sorter if I were buying a new one. It IS very durable though.
53.) Good toy but.........
Reviewed by:
Rating:
I wish the manufacturers would figure out a way to make the lid stay on. It falls off whenever your child turns the box on its side. I had to velcro the lid on.
54.) 12-piece wooden shape sorting cube
Reviewed by: T. Kittle Ben Lomond, CA
Rating:
Great for developmental play for the early toddler and preschooler, however, the cube does not close so peices are constantly falling out and getting lost.
55.) 12 piece wooden shape sorting cube
Reviewed by: disappointed MN USA
Rating:
This item is durable and educational, but not the quality I would give for a gift. It is not made in an attractive format that my little ones were enthusiastic about. By the ime a I paid the postage and cost of the item, it was too costly to send back.
56.) Even hard for me!
Reviewed by: Mermaid
Rating:
Some of these shapes are so similar that even I have a hard time figuring out which whole they go through! This has been a source of great frustration for my 15 month old but he keeps going back and trying over and over. So, I rate this high on education but low on fun. The lid is hard to put in place, but that too is part of the education I suppose. The materials are all durable and seem well made.
57.) Shape sorting cube
Reviewed by: Sherry G. Belford Tybee Island, GA
Rating:
This is a good educational toy; however it is quite challenging for a 2year old to get the shape into the correct slot. Some of shapes are too similar for example the square and the rectangle. The diamond shape when turned is very similar to the rectangle also. It is somewhat frustrating for a young child. I am sure in another 6 months it may not be. I would purchase this shape sorting cube for an older child.
58.) maybe not the best for sorting shapes
Reviewed by: Jonathan Fero Lafayette, Colorado USA
Rating:
We were given this as a baby shower gift and I gave it to my daughter once she was able to sit upright on her own. She has been playing with it for several months. She is not yet at the stage where she is interested in sorting the shapes. She is a big fan of chewing on them and I've noticed the paint has come off on some of the edges. She also likes to put one into a plastic cup (from an Ikea staking cup toy) and shake it around, making noise. Once she started crawling, our little one discovered they quickly slide across the wood floor when she tosses them, and then she loves to retrieve them. I think she likes that the lid comes off easily, because that's the first thing she removes and chews on. Then she drops it on the floor, dumps all the blocks out, and chews on them. Not necessarily its intended purpose! Some of the blocks are smaller than I'd like and I sometimes fear she may choke on them, but I really don't think that is likely.
I suppose that if/when she starts to use it as a shape sorter, she will have to learn to put the shapes that fit into the bottom holes in there first; otherwise, if the bottom of the cube is lined with blocks, you cannot push the star, pentagon, and diamond in (well, maybe a very determined kid could forcefully shove them in and make it work!). I found that to be potentially frustrating myself because it somewhat takes away the fun of randomness out of inserting the blocks.
She (and I) have played with the Fisher Price shape sorter, the plastic one with 4 different shapes (3 pieces of each shape). That one allowed for less creativity because having only four shapes to sort instead of twelve different ones forces the child to learn that one shape fits one hole. If that's what you want, then the Melissa and Doug toy may not be for you, since more than one shape can fit through some of the holes.
59.) melissa & doug are great, but this toy is lacking...
Reviewed by: lovemytwogirls
Rating:
We have tons of Melissa & Doug toys and really are impressed with their overall durability, educational value, and price. However, this is one of the few pieces I would not buy again. The shapes are chunky, varied and colorful, but the design is flawed. It is very difficult for my daughter (received it at one year is now nearly two) to get the shapes in the holes because of the layout. She has other shape sorters that are much more child friendly. Overall this is not an enjoyable toy for her.
60.) Disappointed in the quality
Reviewed by: fraulicious Pittsburgh, PA
Rating:
I was expecting a solid, good quality wooden toy. The cube itself is just that. Beautiful, solid wood, well put together. The rest of the toy disappoints, though. The paint on the blocks started chipping the first time we played with them. The lid is made not from the same wood as the rest of the cube but thinner cheaper laminated wood. Where the cut-out holes are, the first laminated layer has chipped away in places. This doesn't prevent the toy from being played with, however, I am much more wary of my daughter trying to put the blocks in her mouth because of the chipped paint, and it's just not going to be as durable as I expected.
61.) Blocks are good, paint isn't
Reviewed by: Robin B. Meyer
Rating:
My daughter has fun with these blocks and is working on learning the shapes. She is starting to fit them into the holes, and also enjoys stacking them, loading them in and out of the box, and all the other things you can do with a set of blocks! My only complaint about this toy is that, after only a couple months of play, the paint is chipping and peeling off the blocks. I'm glad it's non-toxic, because it's definitely not staying on the wood.
62.) SAFETY IN TOYS
Reviewed by: melvin connally colorado springs, colorado United States
Rating:
THE WOODEN CABINET FOR THE BLOCKS IS HARD WOOD WITH SHARP CORNERS. IF IT WAS MADE OUT OF DURABLE PLASTIC, WITH CURVED CORNERS ITS WOULD BE SAFER AND JUST AS DURABLE.
63.) Great idea, but poor design
Reviewed by: leecookson Burlington, NJ USA
Rating: 
We bought this shape sorter for my older son when he was about 18 months old. He'd already been playing with a lightweight plastic one for months, but we liked that this one was wood and had more shapes -- in addition to the basic oval, circle, rectangle, triangle, square, etc., this one has a flower shape, a heart, an octagon, a couple of different triangles, a wedge, parallelogram, etc.
Unfortunately, the shapes fit through any hole in the sorter, so the child isn't really learning much of anything. Plus, the lid is impossible for a small child to keep on while they're playing with it -- even my older son (now 4) has trouble with it!
I've also found that it gets so crowded in there that the shapes don't always fit well when you're fitting in the last few. You need to shake the sorter so that the shapes settle to the bottom. Another issue that I have with this product is, several of the pieces are small enough to fit INTO a small child's mouth -- our younger son, 18 mos, has proven that on several occasions! The plastic ones we have from the other shape sorter are all a bit larger than these pieces, and I think safer. We keep this shape sorter up on a high shelf, to be played with on a rainy day with supervision. It's not a toy I'd leave out for everyday play.
64.) Looks good, but poor design for actual use
Reviewed by: artsysmartsygrrrl Grand Blanc, MI USA
Rating:
I commend Melissa and Doug for the nice variety of shapes this cube offers as well as its classic wooden toy appearance, but that being said, actual use of this cube is cumbersome and faulty. A bit too heavy for tiny hands to turn and look for the appropriate hole, it also becomes frustrating when the lid falls off (no latch or hinge to keep it on) or it is almost full with blocks and you are trying to push in one of the shapes in the lower portion of the cube and it won't go in because there are blocks inside sitting on the bottom. If the lid latched, you could turn the sides facing up and easily insert the shapes, but not so. I sold my daughter's on ebay and got her the classic plastic Playskool one that has a snap lid and that is lighter weight so she can turn and tumble, looking for the right hole for the shape she has.
65.) Don't waste your money!
Reviewed by: Enzio'sMommy CLINTON TWP., MI United States
Rating:
I agree with the last reviewer...the lid does not lock down-I have it collecting dust on the shelf- I like the idea that it was wood and it is made to last but they should have put a locking lid to keep the shapes in all one piece and so the child can pick up the box with out having the lid fall off.
66.) Poor Design
Reviewed by:
Rating:
The square hole and rectangle hole allows all other shapes to pass through. Young children will think that all shapes fit in squares. Both of my children are not being challenged for they can just put all of the pieces into one hole alone. What is this teaching children? The wrong lesson! Very disappointed.
67.) Tossed shortly after purchase
Reviewed by:
Rating:
This item was purchased for a 1 1/2 yr old. He and I found it very frustrating that the lid kept coming off. He did enjoy putting the shapes in the blocks and learned a little from the cube, however his joy over building with Mega Lego Blocks delivered the cube it's short lived welcome.
68.) Poorly designed Shape Sorter
Reviewed by: Kopal Barnouin-Jha Tokyo, Japan
Rating:
We bought this for our 19 month old because we love the idea of well made wood toys, and she needed a good shape sorter.
This seems to be both of those at first glance. However, when you watch how the kids use this, you realize that they are not learning much. Most of the shapes fit through the hole corresponding to another shape. For instance, the long triangle slides easily through the circle's hole.
Perhaps an older child that knows that you only score points when you play by the rules would be able to use this as intended. Otherwise, my child uses the basic Fisher Price plastic shape sorter (4 shapes, each goes in only if placed in the right hole). That taught her what shape sorters are meant to, and she's very good at it!
This toy ends up being quite confusing; so other than the colorful, well-made pieces being used for parent-child play and instruction (or as projectiles), the toy ends up rather neglected.
69.) WHY????
Reviewed by:
Rating:
Why would this company make the square/rectangle holes so big that every other shape can fit into them. I bought this so my son could learn shapes and now he thinks that all shapes fit in sqauare holes. This toy was a huge disappointment. The quality of the product looks top notch but when you use it you feel robbed!
70.) Too much going on and no fun for a toddler
Reviewed by: MamaB Arizona
Rating:
First, I should say that they must have recently adjusted the design because the lid on the one we just got slides into place, unlike the picture. But it still is frustrating because the design requires you to turn the box over and over to find the right slots, and the lid easily slides out. We had a really great wooden shape sorter Shape Sorting Box by Selecta that our son starting losing interest in after quickly learning how to put all of the shapes (circle, square, triangle, rectangle) into the correct slots. He loved it and will still play with it, but we thought a new challenge might be good for him. This new box is a bad design because even his mother and father who have advanced degrees cannot easily tell the shapes apart perfectly. The parallelogram is so similar to the diamond, both are even yellow, that I have no idea whose toddler wouldn't get frustrated with the toy before learning how to play with it. Also, he is easily distracted by the slots on the sides and front and top that if one shape isn't fitting, he'll give up quickly and go to another slot and then lose interest. I like the idea of having a couple of more complex shapes, but this is ridiculous. Also, the blocks won't fit into even the correct holes sometimes because it fills up and then a new block won't drop in all the way. I am sure I am forgetting several other things that are irritating - bottom line is that you should keep looking for a better shape sorter.
71.) Great Idea..poorly designed
Reviewed by: Victoria P. Labruzzo Newport, RI United States
Rating:
When I had this on our wish list, there were no reviews written about it. When we received it as a Christmas present, we were excited to let our daughter play with it. As soon as we opened it, we couldn't figure out why the lid didn't stay on. You can't turn it without all the blocks falling out! Our daughter still likes to play with it, but it's frustrating for adults because of the terrible design. True, there also some holes that most of the blocks fit through regardless of their shape! I WOULD NOT purchase this...there are many superior products on the market!
72.) Lid falls off too easily
Reviewed by: J. Beattie Florida
Rating:
As others have said, the lid comes completely off. I guess the manufacturer assumes a toddler is going to push the shapes in from the side and not turn the block upside down. Plus I think some of the shapes are a little complex. In addition to the basic shapes, there is a hexagon and a octagon which look very similar to a toddler and they get frustrated when it doesn't go in the hole they think it should.
My daugher's speech therapist has a Playskool form fitter (shape sorter) and it is much better but I can't seem to find it in stock anywhere. It is plastic and the lid snaps shut. The shapes are simpler (star, square, circle, triangle, rectangle, diamond) and there are 2 holes for each shape so you don't have to find just the 1 hole to fit the shape.
73.) Stupid design
Reviewed by: Oaktownmama
Rating:
There's no way to make the lid stay on, so the kid is like "Hmmm, to get the pieces in the box, just put the pieces in THE GIANT HOLE ON THE TOP. No shape sorting necessary." Really terrible design.
74.) Middling Quality, Middling usefulness
Reviewed by: Elise the top of the Delta
Rating:
I am not impressed by the quality of Melissa and Doug products, especially compared to brands like Plan. M&D seems to skimp or wood quality and on the objects' finish. This shape sorter compares unfavorable to Plan's 3-shape sort. The M&D sorter arrived cracked. The blocks aren't very smooth and don't feel great in the hand like Plan's do. And more isn't necessarily better. There are lots of shapes here, but our child likes the box better than sorting, while she loves to sort with the Plan sorter. I'd recommend the simpler, elegant Plan sorter over this one. And coupled with what I've seen of M&D products, I'm going to bypass them from now on and spend a few dollars more for toys that will last multiple children (and grandchildren).
75.) Very difficult - weirdly constructed
Reviewed by: JudiAU Los Angeles
Rating:
This very difficult shape shorter. I would guess that 3+ is a better age range. The shapes are very similar and sized the same. If I sort them by side my 2yold can do it but he doesn't really enjoy it. We have another that is much more fun.
Also, the lid comes off for no reason. I can't see any reason why they would design it this way. At the very least, how about a hinge? Child labor too expensive in China? Like many M&D toys, you get what you pay for...
76.) Good for older children
Reviewed by: Mom of twins Miami FL
Rating:
I thought my twins would love this shape sorter because they love their plastic one. Since it has so many shapes I thought it would be a lot more useful than the plastic one that only has four. Here's a tip, make sure your chid is older than 3 before using this toy. Younger ones want to put the pieces and the lid in their mouth. My daughter got a splinter in her gums from chewing on the lid. Also, it's really hard for toddlers. The shapes are poorly cut so it's not obvious that a parallelogram hole should fit the awkward looking chunk that is supposed to be a 3D parallelogram.
77.) not great
Reviewed by: S. Rhoads
Rating:
there are blocks that are almost the same shape as others; it would be difficult for a young toddler to figure this out. heck, it takes me a minute to do it. the corners are not rounded, so there are sharp wood corners!!
78.) more difficult than it looks
Reviewed by:
Rating:
I picked up one of these shape sorters for my son, who loves puzzles, when he was two. He definitely was interested in it but more often than not "cheated" by putting a piece in the wrong hole by twisting it, or opening the top and dropping it in. His occupational therapist said this puzzle is far more difficult than it looks because of the many surfaces on each block. We put a sticker on one of the surfaces that should face out when you position the block properly and that helped my son figure out how to put the blocks in the right way. Still, I think they should have thought out the design a bit more.
79.) Well this is a good makeshift shape sorter...
Reviewed by: Joni4TA California, United States
Rating:
my kid however, lost the lid to it within a couple days and then it's pretty much a glorified basket!
To each their own!
80.) Not Well Designed
Reviewed by: Ruth Chula Vista, CA United States
Rating: 
I bought this toy because my daughter is really into sorting shapes right now. She has several shape sorters that work really well. This one, however, is not well designed. First of all, the lid cannot be fastened to stay down. When your child needs to turn it over to put in the different shapes they all fall out. Secondly, once you have a couple of shapes in the box they block the way for the others to go in. I have always loved Melissa and Doug toys up to this point but I would love to get my money back for this one.
81.) Just not what a two year old looks for
Reviewed by: Watcher Mom Wisconsin
Rating:
My son got this for his second birthday. He loves to sort shapes. He doesn't like this toy - because the lid falls off! He plays endlessly with the Tupperware shape sorter blue and red ball at a friend's house - he can pick it up and look all around for the right spot for his piece. You can't do that with this box, so we'll be getting him the Tupperware one for Christmas!
82.) bad
Reviewed by: V. Glavach
Rating:
I wish I could have given this item 0 stars...what a waste of money. The lid doesn't stay on, the pieces fit in multiple spots there are enough great shape sorters out there that you don't need to buy this one
83.) Poor design for this classic toy.
Reviewed by: ArRjS Greenville, SC
Rating:
I really wanted to love this toy. It is wooden with so many shapes I thought it would keep my girl entertained and encourage self-confidence. The shape sorter lid has the shape cut outs and comes off completely. You can't turn the piece around to use other sides without it falling off. She takes the lid off and doesn't know to try to put shapes through it. It would have been much better to have a hole with a latch on the solid bottom to get the pieces out. I have to tape the lid on it get her to play with it right.
84.) What's the point?
Reviewed by: Krystin San Diego, CA
Rating:
I bought this for my 2 year old, and as soon as I opened it I knew it was a mistake. First of all the lid doesn't stay on - especially when you have to shake the cube so all the shapes fit inside. Then he started putting the shapes in the wrong holes. So, what's the point? Don't they test these toys before they sell them? Just curious...
85.) Not worth it
Reviewed by: A savvy shopper New Jersey
Rating:
I bought this toy for my 21 month old thinking she would love it. Like other reviewers, my daughter isn't that interested in her old shape sorter so I thought I would pick up this one, since it seemed more age appropriate and a bit more complicated. My BIG issue with this sorter is that there is no hinge on the lid. My daughter immediately figured out(as most children would) she can simply take the lid off then toss the shapes in the box. The lack of the lid closing takes the challenge away. I was very unipressed. I would wait until a better version comes out before purchasing this product.
86.) This toy is frustrating, the lid does not stay on!
Reviewed by: wisutri Low Country, SC
Rating:
I bought this for my son and how the lid is made it does not stay on so that you may turn it to put the different shapes in. Also, when putting shapes in, it gets so full that other shapes will not fit in with out a fight. I would highly recommend tupperware's shape sorter before I would ever buy this one.
87.) Top isn't hinged on and bad construction...WOULDN'T BUY AGAIN.
Reviewed by: Rhonda Mankin
Rating:
Melissa and Doug Products could use some work..We bought the shape sorter for christmas and not 2 weeks later the top split. Now there is no top and 3 blocks are basically useless. Also the paint on the blocks doesn't stay on very well. We ordered about ten differen M&D products and really aren't happy with quality, size or construction. The paints on most of their products is already coming off or chipping away. The wood on some has broken or splintered away. Now I must say our daughter is 11 months old and not rough on any of them.
I would be careful if you do purchase and keep plenty of glue around for all the broken pcs.
88.) Disappointing for sorting intentions
Reviewed by: safmom Oak Park, Illinois United States
Rating:
This toy just sets a kid up to fail. So many great shapes, but so useless for all the reasons already stated--the top comes right off and the pieces fall out as you turn the box. My 20 month old son does enjoy stacking the shapes. I have now put the box away so he doesn't get frustrated at not succeeding.
89.) what is the point?
Reviewed by: KellyAnn Kenna Philadelphia, PA
Rating:
My husband and I bought this because it looked great...a wooden shape sorter. Yeah, okay. First the lid doesn't stay on. Second, my 17 month old learned about 5 minutes into playing with it (he started a few months ago), that the blocks don't necessarily have to go into the shape it corresponds with. Now it's pretty much a noise maker. Dump the blocks out and put them back in. Don't waste your child's time with this one...the same thing can be accomplished with some dry pasta and a shoe box with a few holes cut in the side.
90.) Broke after 12 hours
Reviewed by: Greg's Mom NY
Rating:
VERY flimsy wood. The lid snapped in half after about 12 hours. Some of the shapes are so similar to each other that it becomes frustrating for my almost 2 year old to play with. I mean honestly, is it really necessary to have a pentagon, hexagon and octogon in a shape sorter? Also, the lid doesn't have a hinge, so when he turns the box to figure out where the block goes, the lid comes off and anything he had in there falls out. We've thrown out the box and just play with the blocks. So sorry I wasted the money. Thank goodness it wasn't that expensive.
91.) I love Melissa & Doug toys, but this is a big disappointment
Reviewed by:
Rating:
I ditto the majority of the reviews of this toy. Although I really like most of the Melissa & Doug toys, I cannot figure out how this one is still on the market...Again, the fact that the lid will not stay on makes the toy nearly useless. The child cannot turn the cube in any direction to find the proper hole for the shape,and if she does, the top falls off or the block falls out. What is the point? It becomes just another box to keep blocks in.
My 21 month old daughter simply takes the blocks and dumps them in other containers, it is completely useless as a shape sorter...I have to say it was a big waste of money, unlike the other toys by this manufacturer.
92.) poorly constructed
Reviewed by:
Rating:
I really can't imagine how this toy was tested! The lid does not secure onto the box, and falls off every time the box is turned, and if you don't turn the box then it fills up so that there is no space to insert the shapes. Additionally some holes allow other shapes to pass through them. A very poor choice.
93.) Who thought of this ridiculous toy?
Reviewed by: Jennifer Atlanta, GA
Rating:
The lid comes off immediately. We thought it was defective so we brought it back to Toys R Us and got a new one but that is the way it is designed. What kid could or would want to hold the lid the entire time they are playing with the toy to make sure it doesn't come off. Also, our son would just put the shapes in the open side once the lid fell off or he'd get upset that everything he put into the shape sorter fell out.
I cannot imagine anyone tested this product. Toys R Us makes a wooden shape sorter that is much more environmentally friendly and no danger of lead. That one has a side that slides off and it's easy enough for a 2 year old to figure out but not so easy that it falls off. That one was a much better idea. What were Melissa and Doug thinking here.
[...]
94.) Poor Design
Reviewed by: Wiiildflowers4Jade Nashville
Rating:
I usually like Melissa and Doug, but this is a very poorly designed product. The box is made with shapes on five sides, obviously to play you should be able to turn the box at different angles. But the lid just sits on top, so it falls off if you turn it. It's a useless box with shapes cut in it, waste of money.
95.) lid falls off, what more to say?
Reviewed by: JohnnyC Alexandria, VA (USA)
Rating:
A complete waste of money -- the child cannot manipulate the cube to look at different sides, because there is no latch that holds the lid on! It simply falls off, and all the shape blocks fall out, too. Very angry to have purchased this. What a ripoff.
96.) Flaking Paint!
Reviewed by: bookworm PA
Rating:
I ordered this shape sorter for two reasons. There are many more shapes than in most of the others that I've looked at, and I like wooden toys. My grandson enjoyed playing with the shapes; however, after having this toy for a few months, the paint began to flake off. His parents noticed the flakes of paint on his face and threw the toy away. I am concerned about the safety of such a toy!
97.) The paint chipped off.
Reviewed by: AnneSAHM Southeast Iowa
Rating:
I bought this shape sorter for my daughter. After only a few times playing with it, the paint started to chip off of the blocks.
Very poorly made.
98.) Not Child Safe
Reviewed by: to honest TX
Rating:
I purchased this item for my son. He just loves to play with it. But, after two days the lid split in two. My son is very gentle with his toys. The wood had a weak spot and was already cracked prior to opening and a block as well. Thank goodness I did not turn away when a piece of the block broke off. My son eats everything, he would have choked, or much worse. So far the rest of the toy seams to be fine. But I just had to toss it. Could not take a chance on any other pieces falling apart. I would pay more money for better quality wood. cheaper is not always the way to go.I am surprised this item has not been recalled. I see from other reviews this happens quite often. I like Melissa & Doug's products. But, don't waste your money on this one. I will try the tupperware sorter recommended per one review.
99.) PRODUCT BEING RECALLED****UNSAFE FOR CHILDREN
Reviewed by: moviecritichead New York, NY
Rating:
**********PRODUCT RECALLED UNSAFE FOR CHILDREN*************************
Hazard Identified
Testing by Health Canada has revealed that the surface paint on the toys contains barium in excess of the allowable limit.
Some forms of barium are safely used in medical and commercial applications, while other forms of barium can be toxic, causing adverse health effects such as nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and cramps as well as more severe symptoms. Children's toys coated with paint containing barium in excess of the allowable limit are strictly prohibited in Canada.
Health Canada has not received any reports of incidents or illnesses related to the use of this product.
For some tips to help consumers choose safe toys and to help them keep children safe when they play with toys, see Health Canada's: Toy Safety Tips.
Corrective Action
Consumers should immediately take the recalled toys away from children.
100.) Toy recalled in Canada for unsafe levels of barium
Reviewed by: C. Jackson Honolulu, HI
Rating:
I've had this toy for a while and my 10 month old daughter has chewed on the blocks (which the paint does chip off pretty easily). Now I found that this toy was actually recalled in Canada due to unsafe levels of barium! I'm staying away from all Melissa & Doug toys as some of their other products have also been recalled. Why doesn't US have stricter laws concerning childrens toys!!
From Consumer product safety Canada
Slice and Bake Cookie set, Shape Sorting Cube, and Pound a Peg by Melissa & Doug
Testing by Health Canada has revealed that the surface paint on the toys contains barium in excess of the allowable limit.
Some forms of barium are safely used in medical and commercial applications, while other forms of barium can be toxic, causing adverse health effects such as nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and cramps as well as more severe symptoms. Children's toys coated with paint containing barium in excess of the allowable limit are strictly prohibited in Canada.
Health Canada has not received any reports of incidents or illnesses related to the use of this product.
101.) Very poor quality, DANGEROUS
Reviewed by: Elizabeth Las Vegas, NV
Rating:
Unfortunately, I bought this toy on a whim at the store when I usually read reviews first and I highly regret it. This product is of very poor quality. We have owned it for 2 days. Like others have said, the lid is too easy to remove and just slides right out by merely turning the cube. Not too much of an issue (right now anyway) because my kid is of an age where she just likes to remove the shapes from the box and not put them back. What concerns me the most though are the splinters. Mine has splinters of a good enough size that they could be a choking hazard on in addition to "just" poking into skin. The box is just splintering off around the shape holes. I took this immediately away from my child. Too bad. I'm going to try and return it.
102.) Unfortunately not up to LCI standards
Reviewed by:
Rating:
I love LCI products.. especially their fuzzy puzzzles :)
However, this one doesn't live up to my expectations
Problems:
1) The top doesn't stay on. What's the point if you can't put all of the shapes in. When you turn it the top falls off and the shapes fall out. It's not even hinged.
2) There are some pieces that will fit through the wrong hole.
103.) Junk
Reviewed by: JAC and Ben's Mom Ronkonkoma, NY United States
Rating:
What a waste of wood. The lid falls off when you turn it to put peices in the side. I can't believe Lights, Camera, Interaction made this.
104.) Good idea, bad design
Reviewed by: San Fran driver San Francisco, CA USA
Rating:
My 2 year old daughter loves to play with the cube, but she (and I) get frustraged because the lid does NOT, not stay on at ALL once you turn the cube to get to the other shapes and all the pieces you had inside spill out and you got to start all over again, it needs velcro, a latch or something.
Don't waste your money.
105.) Recalled
Reviewed by: love JERSEY CITY, NJ, US
Rating:
This item has been recalled in Canada, along with the shape pound a peg and sorting stacker, and several other products for barium. I wish I had known this months ago. My child had all 3 items.
106.) Bad Choice
Reviewed by:
Rating:
I purchased this toy thinking like everyone else that it seemed great in the box. However, outside the box it is useless. The top does not stay on. I called Melissa & Doug and informed them of the flaw in the product. They explained that they did not attach the cover out of fear of little fingers being caught in the "door" when child tries to close the top. I am still sure there are work arounds. I personally LOVE Melissa & Doug products, but NOT this product. They have a great customer service!
107.) They Missed The Point
Reviewed by:
Rating:
Very Cute.
Doesn't work.
My son puts any shape he wants into any hole which defeats the purpose of the toy. The best shape sorter I had was a clear bucket with 4 basic shapes on the top - I gave it away but wish I could find that one again for my 2nd child. I'm giving this toy away too though I feel badly about offering a toy that does not work as it is intended.
108.) Don't miss the point of this real-life teaching toy
Reviewed by: Gary Fixler Los Angeles, California United States
Rating:
I'm afraid previous posts may fail to properly shed light on the ingenius levels of parody involved in the brilliant design of this "toy." Through its enigmatic skirtings around the core purpose for its existence, it has probably taught children more about the real world than its more properly-functioning competitors could hope to.
From employee laziness and corporate indifference, to "first to market" rush and "committee decisions," your child will learn that life isn't fair, an important and inevitable lesson that overprotective parents often shield from their children until time and age amplify its effects beyond reason. They'll also learn that with a little shove, and a quick peek to make sure no one's any the wiser, you can do something the wrong way, and get the job done in a fraction of the time.
If you're upset that the lid comes off when turned upside down, remember that too often, management will ask you to turn everything upside down, causing the lid to come off and all your blocks to tumble out. Of course, in this case, the blocks will be things like your social life, or 20 other things you're trying to juggle for your other 3 managers. This fantastic toy teaches toddlers that once the boss isn't looking, a shortcut can be sought that will both conserve worker energy (and web-surfing time), while getting the job done pretty much the same way with a minimal amount of thought and effort. This will help relieve stress and save money in the long run when they don't need to purchase self-help CDs, or book time with a therapist or three.
This toy is a wonderful parody of your little one's probable future office life. I plan on getting one for my desk at work as a retro office toy and subtle reminder that good things come to those who know that while everything can fit easily through the rectangular hole with no effort on my part, the boss doesn't know that, and thinks I'm a genius. I recommend sitting your child down with this toy in front of "Office Space" available here in the DVD section.
109.) scary
Reviewed by: worried mom queens, ny
Rating:
my child received this as a gift but i do not recomend you buy this item. is a wooden box with sharp edges, my husband tripped on this box and cut his knee, it has since been away from my son and on a shelf. that's all the use we will be giving to it. just the thought of my child hurting himself with this box scares me.
Activity Centers